Here’s something I see all the time. A homeowner walks outside and notices a few missing shingles. Or a cracked tile. Or a water stain spreading across the bedroom ceiling. So they do what makes sense: they pick up the phone, call their insurance company, and open a claim themselves.
Then the adjuster asks the question: "What’s your date of loss?"
And the homeowner gives them a date. Maybe it’s the day they noticed the damage. Maybe it’s the day they called. Maybe it’s a guess, something like "I think it was around the end of August."
A few weeks later, the denial letter shows up. Wear and tear. Age related deterioration. No evidence of a covered wind event.
Here’s what happened. The carrier took the date you gave them, pulled the weather data for your address on that exact day, and saw winds of 15 or 20 miles per hour. And a 20 mile per hour breeze doesn’t tear up a roof. Claim closed. Next.
What the Date of Loss Actually Is
The date of loss is the date the damage actually happened. Not the date you noticed it. Not the date you got around to calling. The date the storm hit and did the damage.
In Florida, that date controls a lot more than people realize. It starts the clock on your deadline to report the claim, which under Fla. Stat. § 627.70132 is generally one year from the date of loss for a new claim. It can decide which deductible applies, your regular deductible or your hurricane deductible. And it’s the date the carrier uses to check the weather.
Get that date wrong and you’re basically handing the insurance company the denial on a silver platter.
Why Wind Speed Is Everything
Roofs are built to handle wind. That’s the whole point. A shingle roof, a tile roof, a metal roof, they’re all designed to sit up there through normal Florida weather, afternoon thunderstorms included, without falling apart.
So when you claim wind damaged your roof, the first thing the carrier wants to know is simple: was there actually enough wind to do it? Shingles need wind strong enough to lift, crease, or tear them off. Tile is heavy, so it takes serious wind, or flying debris, to crack or displace it, and carriers love to blame cracked tiles on somebody walking on the roof. Metal roofs need enough force to lift panels, loosen fasteners, or peel back seams.
Hail is the other big one. If there are hail reports in your area on your date of loss, that changes the conversation completely. If there aren’t, expect the carrier to say whatever marks are on your roof came from something else.
I’ve seen claims where the roof was clearly damaged, real damage, and the claim still got denied because the homeowner gave a date where nothing more than a light breeze rolled through. The damage was real. The date was wrong. That’s all it took.
Now, Let Me Be Very Clear About Something
When I say pick the right date, I do not mean pick a convenient date. Your date of loss has to be the date the damage really happened. Do not make one up. Do not move it around to fit the weather. Giving the insurance company a date you know isn’t true is a fast way to turn a covered claim into a fraud accusation, and that’s a much bigger problem than a denial.
What I’m telling you is the opposite of guessing. Use the weather data to figure out which storm actually did the damage. If you know the damage showed up sometime in a certain window, look at what storms rolled through during that window. More often than not, the event with the strongest wind gusts or confirmed hail is the one that did it. That’s the date you want to identify, because it’s the truth, and because the data backs it up.
How to Check Before You Call
You don’t need to be a meteorologist. Here’s what I’d do:
• Narrow down the window. When was the last time you know for sure the roof was fine? When did you first notice the problem?
• Look up the storms in that window. NOAA’s National Centers for Environmental Information has a free Storm Events Database, and the National Weather Service publishes local storm reports, including hail. Historical data from nearby weather stations helps too.
• Look at the numbers, not just the headlines. What were the peak wind gusts near your property? Were there hail reports, and how big was the hail?
• Match it to your damage. Does the timing line up with when the leak started or when you noticed the missing shingles or cracked tiles?
• Write it down and keep it. Screenshots, links, dates. If the carrier pushes back, you want your homework ready.
And honestly, if you’re not sure, call a lawyer before you call the insurance company. That first phone call gets recorded, written into the claim notes, and the carrier is going to hold you to every word of it for the rest of the claim.
The Bottom Line
The insurance company is going to look at the weather data. That’s not a maybe. It’s one of the very first things they do. So you should look at it first. Know what storm did the damage, know what the wind speeds were, know whether there was hail, and then make the call.
If your roof claim already got denied because of the date of loss or because the carrier says the weather didn’t support it, that’s not necessarily the end of the road.
Important Disclaimer
Attorney Advertising. This article is attorney advertising.
Responsible Lawyer and Offices. The lawyer responsible for this content is Louis P. Meyer, Esq., Florida Bar No. 1024811, of Kanner & Pintaluga, P.A., with bona fide offices in Tampa and Boca Raton, Florida. Firm mailing address: 6600 N. Military Trail, 2nd Floor, Boca Raton, FL 33496.
No Legal Advice. This article is for general informational and educational purposes only. It is not legal advice and should not be relied on as legal advice for any specific situation. Every claim and every policy is different.
No Attorney Client Relationship. Reading this article, commenting on it, or contacting the author does not create an attorney client relationship. An attorney client relationship is formed only after a written fee agreement has been signed by both the client and the firm. Please do not send confidential information until that happens.
Deadlines. Insurance claims and lawsuits are subject to strict deadlines set by your policy and by Florida law, including deadlines to report a claim and to file suit. Missing a deadline can bar your claim entirely. If you have a potential claim, speak with a lawyer promptly.
Prior Results. Any results or examples discussed do not guarantee or predict a similar outcome in any future matter. Each case depends on its own facts and law.
No Specialization Claim. Louis P. Meyer is not board certified by The Florida Bar in any area of law, and nothing in this article should be read as a claim of specialization or expertise.
Scope and Referrals. Kanner & Pintaluga may refer matters to, or work with, other lawyers or firms. If that happens, you will be told in advance and your written consent will be obtained as required by the Rules Regulating The Florida Bar.
Fees and Costs. Many property damage and personal injury matters are handled on a contingency fee basis, meaning no attorney fee unless there is a recovery. Clients may still be responsible for certain costs depending on the terms of the written agreement. Fee arrangements are explained in writing before representation begins.
Currency of Law. Florida insurance law changes frequently. The information in this article reflects the law as of its publication date and may not reflect later changes in statutes, rules, or case law.
Choosing a Lawyer. The hiring of a lawyer is an important decision that should not be based solely upon advertisements. Before you decide, ask us to send you free written information about our qualifications and experience.
Aviso en Español. Este artículo es publicidad de abogados y es solo para fines informativos. No constituye asesoramiento legal ni crea una relación de abogado y cliente. Se habla español.