After Hurricane Isaias came through the Panhandle, the Pensacola News Journal told a story that played out on street after street. A big tree comes down in the yard. It misses the house. It misses the fence, the car, everything. The homeowner is relieved for about an hour, and then the quotes start coming in, and the relief ends.
Getting a large fallen tree cut up and hauled away is not a few hundred dollars of yard work. The quotes reported after the storm ran from $2,500 to $20,000, depending on the size of the tree, how tangled the job is, and how close the work sits to roofs and power lines. Most homeowners assume the insurance company pays that bill, or at the very least that the money counts toward the hurricane deductible. In the usual case, neither one is true.
If the tree hits nothing, there is usually no claim
Homeowners insurance is built to respond to damage to covered property. The house is covered property. The fence and the garage are covered property. A tree lying across the lawn, by itself, has damaged nothing the policy insures, so there is generally no covered loss for the carrier to pay on, and the cost of cutting it up and hauling it off is the homeowner’s bill. That surprises people, because the storm caused the tree to fall and the storm is a covered event. But the policy follows the damage, not the weather. Damage to the yard alone is, in the eyes of the policy, cleanup. And cleanup after a storm is one of the largest uninsured expenses Florida homeowners meet, storm after storm.
Policies vary, and some carry small amounts of coverage for debris or landscaping in narrow situations, so the declarations and endorsements of your own policy are the last word. But the general rule reported after Isaias is the rule homeowners should plan around. A tree that hits nothing usually pays nothing.
Why the removal bill does not move your deductible
The second hard truth is about the math. A Florida hurricane deductible is satisfied by covered losses under the policy. Covered losses. Money you spend out of your own pocket on a cost the policy never covered does not get credited against that deductible, no matter how storm related the expense feels.
Put numbers on it. Your home is insured for $400,000 and your hurricane deductible is 2 percent. That deductible is $8,000. A tree service charges you $10,000 to clear the oak off your lawn. You have not satisfied one dollar of the $8,000. If the same storm also cracked roof tiles and water got in, the roof and water damage are covered losses that count toward the deductible in the way the policy measures them. The $10,000 tree bill still sits outside the math, on its own ledger, in your column. Homeowners who budget a cleanup job as progress toward their deductible are doing arithmetic the carrier will never honor.
When the tree does hit something, paper wins
Everything changes when the tree lands on a covered structure. A tree through the roof, across the fence, or into the garage is a covered claim for the damage to that structure, and how that claim goes depends heavily on what gets captured before the saws start.
Photograph before anyone cuts. Wide shots showing the whole tree and what it struck, then close shots of the impact point, the roof surface, the broken truss or fence line. Take a slow video walkthrough while you narrate the date and what you are looking at. Keep every written quote you collect, not just the one you accept, and keep the final invoice itemized, showing what was cut, what was hauled, and what any emergency work cost. Save receipts for tarping and other steps taken to keep water out of the opening. Keep it all in one folder, physical or digital, because six months later nobody’s memory of that week is as good as the paper.
That record does two jobs. It proves the condition of the property before the emergency cleanup changed it, which is exactly the gap carriers point to when a claim gets questioned. And it seperates the covered structure damage from the uncovered yard work cleanly, so the argument stays about the claim and not about what a pile of brush in a photograph might have been.
The rule of thumb is worth taping to the refrigerator before the next storm. Insurance responds to damage to the home. It does not, in the usual case, respond to the mess by itself, and it does not credit what you spend on the mess toward your deductible. The homeowners who fare best after a storm are the ones who knew that before the tree came down, and who reached for a camera before they reached for a chainsaw.
About the Author
Louis P. Meyer, Esq. is a Senior Attorney at Kanner & Pintaluga, P.A. in Tampa, Florida, where his practice focuses on personal injury cases and first party property damage claims across Florida, including car, motorcycle, and truck accidents, and hurricane, wind, water, fire, and mold losses. He writes the LouisTheLawyer publication on Substack and hosts the podcast Off The Record by Louis Meyer. He practices from the firm’s Tampa and Boca Raton offices. This article is general information about how insurance claims work in Florida. It is not legal advice about any specific accident or policy.
Louis P. Meyer, Esq., Senior Attorney, Kanner & Pintaluga, P.A., 100 S. Ashley Drive, Suite 610, Tampa, FL 33602. Phone: 561-206-2949. Email: lmeyer@kpattorney.com.
Attorney Advertising. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome.
Contingency fee cases: the client may be responsible for court costs and litigation expenses regardless of the outcome. Attorney’s fees and costs are computed as set out in the written fee agreement.